Suburban

When I first read about this cocktail, I was immediately intrigued by the combination of ingredients. Rum plays well with most of the bar, but dark rum is slightly less social. Whiskey occasionally finds itself escorted by a bit of sweet vermouth or triple sec, but when compared to vodka, whiskey looks pretty shy. I'd never heard of putting them both in the same drink, and adding port to the party seemed like a recipe for disaster! I had to try it.

To my surprise, the result was something like a Manhattan, but sweeter, and much more assertive. The bitters add a complexity that can only be found in the classic cocktails from before Prohibition. Through experimentation I discovered that the most satisfying Suburban is shaken very well. Tiny ice chips floating on a foamy surface give the drink a refreshing arctic texture while the extra time in the shaker smoothes out the dry sting of the straight rye. While the source I found mentioned no garnish, I find that a Maraschino cherry gives a sweet finish to a very satisfying drink.

By my calculations, this cocktail comes out to about 80 proof (or 40% Alcohol by Volume), give or take a few points for adding the bitters and then shaking the cocktail over ice. So even though it has a healthy amount of Rye (typically 101 Proof or 50.5% ABV), this cocktail competes with a typical dry martini. Given the sugars native to rum and port, I imagine its calorie count to be slightly higher.

This bit of nostalgia hails from the illustrious Waldorf-Astoria, a luxury hotel in New York, famous for its recipes in an era where cocktails were king. It's namesake is the Suburban Handicap, a horse race that first took place in Brooklyn (circa 1884), and then later in Queens. The quirky classic has earned a special place in my heart and I hope to bring it back to compete with its more famous playmates in today's cocktail world.

Ingredients
Glassware: Cocktail Glass
1 oz Straight Rye Whiskey (Wild Turkey makes a Straight Rye, as well as Old Overholt, but my favorite is Rittenhouse Bottled in Bond)
1/2 oz Ruby Port (I find the red color of ruby is preferable to Tawny's brown hue)
1/2 oz Dark Rum (I like Myer's Dark or Whalers)
Dash Orange Bitters
Dash Angostura Bitters
Garnish: Maraschino Cherry

Instructions
Chill a Cocktail Glass on the bar using ice and soda
Fill a Boston Shaker with ice
Combine all ingredients
Shake and strain into a Cocktail Glass
Garnish with a Maraschino cherry